Rockville Church of Christ
What is MODERNISM?
I Hear "Postmodern" A Lot...So What is MODERNISM?

What Do We Mean by
"Modernism"?
Modernism
as an era in human history, especially in Western society, marks a period
characterized by confidence in reason, natural law, and secular humanism. The
mood of the modern period was an optimism that humanity was progressing in its
discovery of absolute truth and working toward human solutions to the world's
greatest problems like poverty, ignorance, war, and, for many, even religion.
The period was marked by a transition from faith in Divine Revelation to
reliance on human reason alone.
Some Influential Figures
on the Modern Era
- René
Descartes (1596-1650) -- Mathematician and philosopher who
wanted to prove God's existence but started with doubt instead of faith.
Beginning with human reason as his premise, he arrived at the logical
conclusion: "I think, therefore I am." Descartes' legacy for future generations
was his influence on the shift from faith and theocentric reasoning to doubt
and humanistic reasoning.
- Copernicus
(1473-1543), Galileo (1564-1642), and Kepler (1571-1630) --
Astronomers whose collective work demonstrated the errors in the traditional
geocentric models that claimed the earth as the center of the universe and the
revolving of all planetary bodies in perfect circular orbits around the earth.
The implications of the rejection of some of traditional science led to
questioning of traditional theology as well.
- Baruch
Spinoza (1632-1677) -- Laid the groundwork for the rise
of the Historical Critical Method of studying the Bible, which does not start
with the assumption of inspiration of the Scriptures but rather looks at other
theories of the origin and "editing" of the text before reaching its final
form. This method has dominated much of biblical scholarship for at least the
last 200 years and has led to many influential "scholars" becoming increasingly
skeptical of the inspiration of Scripture.
- David
Hume (1711-1776) -- Enlightenment philosopher whose work
largely consisted of skepticism of religion and the rejection of any biblical
or historical claims of miracles. In Hume's mind, the physical or material
world was a closed system of natural laws which could not be "violated" by
supernatural intervention. He saw no evidence for miracles in his time and
therefore argued by analogy that they never took place. Belief in a
supernatural being who tried to "suspend" those laws of nature was not rational.
Hume's influence led to the rise of Deism (a belief in a Creator God who stays
distant from His Creation) and eventually to an increase in Agnosticism (a
claim that we can't know if God exists or not) and outright Atheism.
- John
Locke (1632-1704), Voltaire (1694-1778), Jean-Jacques Rousseau
(1712-1778), Thomas Paine (1737-1809), and other
Enlightenment Philosophers -- Following down Descartes' road of focus on human
rationalism, the Enlightenment era questioned traditional political monarchies
and their suppression of man's natural rights derived from a "natural law."
They were highly influential on movement toward democracy, often through
political revolutions -- most notably the American and the French. Many
Enlightenment figures were also skeptical and in some cases vocally critical of
any religious institutions such as the various Christian churches in the
Western world. "We hold these truths to be self-evident" begins with focus on
man instead of God.
- Charles
Darwin (1809-1882) -- Author of The Origin of Species and founder of the Theory of Evolution, which
has obviously had a profound influence on scientific thought and society in
general. Maybe not his intention, but Darwin's legacy is marked by a movement in
academics toward a dominance of natural science among the disciplines and
emphasis on the explanation of human origins and purpose without God in the
picture.
- Karl
Marx (1818-1883) -- Author of The Communist Manifesto, which heavily influenced figures such as
Vladimir Lenin, Mao Zedong, and other world leaders who led revolutions in
places like Russia and China in order to set up new socio-economic and
political systems in which faith in anything other than secular humanism was
violently suppressed.
- Friedrich
Nietzsche (1844-1900) -- Philosopher who may be best known
for his statement, "God is dead," claiming that humanity was killing God off by
entering into a new age of "nihilism" -- a worldview that fails to find purpose
or meaning in life. Although Nietzsche himself turned to nihilism, he also
warned of the depths of atrocities the world was about to be plunged into with
no standard of moral authority. His concept of the "Super-Man" who would exert
his superiority over weaker men and establish his own moral code for humanity
appears to have had a profound influence on Adolf Hitler and his assertion of
the Master Aryan Race.
- Sigmund
Freud (1856-1939) -- Known as the father of psychoanalysis,
his worked spanned a variety of aspects of human psychology, a notable one
being the connection between the mind and sexual desire. With a pessimistic
view of humanity's future in Civilization
and Its Discontents, Freud saw God as an illusion out of the human desire
for a supernatural reality and the suppression of violence.
If the World is Now
"Post-Modern," What Happened to Modernism?
The
optimism of the secular modernist spirit came crashing down through the two
World Wars of the first half of the 20th-Century. The World Wars
proved that humanity was not progressing in morality and its ability to fix its
problems. We were just as savage as ancient man. Our Tower of Babel of reaching
the heavens through our own accomplishments and making a name for ourselves
came crashing down with a thud.
Positives from the Modern
Era
The
Modern Era was marked by amazing scientific discoveries and technological
advancements, many of which have improved the function of the world as a whole.
A belief in real truth was definitely a positive. The use of human reason was
not the problem. The search for absolute truth and the metanarrative of
humanity was not the problem. The problem lied in arrogantly divorcing reason
from revelation, distancing truth from its source, and failing to see Jesus
Christ as the centerpiece in the world's metanarrative.
The Bottom Line
Absolute
truth exists, and it belongs to God. He reveals the portions that we discover
both through the revelation of His Word and through reason of a mind made in
His image. But we should never have the arrogance to claim either to know all
truth or to be able to fix all the world's problems.
"The
secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things revealed belong to us
and our sons forever..." (Deuteronomy
29:29)
To His Glory,
Caleb